While the babysitter is with his children are at the arcade, his son is tricked and captured by Trinity. After Scott goes missing, Nick calls the police and puts out an Amber Alert for his son. Soon their house is filled with volunteers desperately trying to find Scott, including a visit from Dexter Morgan. Eventually, Dexter finds Scott just as he is being buried alive and rescues him. Nick is reunited with his son. However, saving Scott Smith allows Trinity to escape from Dexter.
Later, Nick is seen by his son's side while he is being interviewed by Debra Morgan. Scott recalls how his captor kidnapped and drugged him and draws a picture of the Four Walls One Heart logo. His statement allows the police to identify Trinity as Arthur Mitchell.