She was kidnapped by the Doomsday Killer in order to be sacrificed in The Whore of Babylon Tableau. While Holly was held captive, she was berated for being a sinner, forced to drink blood, and suffered with an untreated broken arm. After she claimed to have a young son, Travis Marshall was unable to brand her. He then relented and set her free.
Later, Travis regretted letting Holly go and decided to remedy his mistake. He tracked Holly to a boat (named the Ricochet Rabbit) that was owned by her boyfriend, Peter Grant. With the assistance of his disciples, Steve and Beth Dorsey, Travis re-captured Holly, tied her to a chair, and slashed her throat. Steve finished the job by stabbing her through the chest. Her body was then fastened to the boat's anchor and lowered into the water.